Connect with us

Chelsea

Chelsea’s defensive dilemma – lose Thiago Silva or sign Todibo?

Chelsea have reportedly been trying to advance a deal for OGC Nice centre-back Jean-Clair Todibo amidst interest from Manchester United.

Tottenham Hotspur also showed interest in Todibo but struggled to get the deal going and have now turned to Genoa’s Radu Dragusin.

The race for Todibo’s signature is now between Manchester United and Chelsea. However, whispers of Thiago Silva’s potential exit raise a crucial question – is this a defensive upgrade or a costly gamble?

The Blues would like to add Todibo to bolster their backline that has leaked goals for fun in recent games.

The talented 24-year-old has been one of the shining spots for Nice as they sit second in Ligue 1 after conceding only nine goals this term.

Todibo has won 57% of his duels, acting as a sweeper for his more aggressive and experienced partner, Dante.

While Todibo’s talent is undeniable, his arrival throws Chelsea’s defensive stability into the spotlight. 

Chelsea’s interest in Todibo looks solid, but his addition will only push Silva out of the door, which could be a net negative for the club.


Silva is 39 and declining but remains their defensive leader and levels ahead of the other options Chelsea have at centre-half.

Todibo cannot bring the experience, calm and authority that Silva brings to Chelsea’s immature backline.

Chelsea’s defensive options include Malo Gusto, Benoit Badiashile, Ian Maatsen and Levi Colwill, and they need Silva’s experience to anchor them.

In Chelsea’s latest fixture against Luton Town, the Brazilian helped prevent his side from conceding a disastrous third that would have allowed the Hatters to secure a 3-3 draw. 

Silva’s crucial interventions prevented a late collapse, highlighting his irreplaceable value.

He was also the only one to show disappointment after they conceded twice to allow Luton back into the game despite their 3-0 lead. It speaks volumes about his commitment and defensive nous.

Silva is a vital cog that Chelsea cannot afford to lose now. They should be working on extending his deal beyond this summer, as his departure will mean the loss of key experience. 

While Todibo is a stellar signing, the Blues need to work on moving on underwhelming Axel Disasi or Wesley Fofana, who has sustained two long-term injuries since his arrival for €70 million.

Todibo’s potential is enticing, but Chelsea must proceed with caution. 

Prioritising Silva’s retention and offloading underperforming defenders are crucial before considering integrating a young talent like Todibo. 

Otherwise, they risk replacing stability with uncertainty and jeopardising their defensive solidity.

More in Chelsea